ART: An Emotional Bridge?
By Judy Marshall, Ph.D.


[En español]



When I was in my early teens, I tried to spend every Saturday I could at the local art museum, sneaking into the city without my parents’ permission. Smaller than the Metropolitan in New York, but still noteworthy (not that I would have known), the museum was extraordinary and wondrous to me. It had numerous halls and galleries that re-created typical rooms and environments from different periods of history and throughout the world. I would be transported to the extravagant excesses of 17th century France, the somber aura of a Medieval monastery, the sunlit home of a Roman patrician, the delicate and lush garden of an 18th century Japanese tea house. It was like walking into a labyrinthine time machine… a dream world of other places and long ago. Although it took a bit more imagination, I had that same feeling wandering among the paintings, each providing entrance into distant dimensions of place and time, even to mythical worlds.

By the time I reached college, I had started collecting postcards of my favorite works of art. I treasured my ever-increasing assortment, which adorned the walls of dorm rooms and studio walk-ups for the next several years. Even as a student without money, I was very discerning about what made it into my “collection.” Each painting or sculpture pictured on the four-by-six inch cards had to speak to me in a very specific way, although I couldn’t verbalize what that was. The important thing seemed to be this intense, inexplicable personal connection. I wasn’t yet a psychologist, but I did have the understanding that each work reflected something uniquely and quintessentially important to me. Were these aspects of my “self?” (Maybe even seminal parts of my own personality that, young as I was, were still waiting to be discovered?)

Because I have been fortunate to have art in my life (even through a bunch of postcards), I have experienced its cathartic benefits. I have felt how soothing it can be on a day-to-day basis and have seen this effect on others. A piece of art has the capacity to take us into a trancelike space or reverie. It has an “energy” or vibe or tone that affects mood and even outlook. It can be a “friend” that accompanies us during a difficult time. It can be a continuing, but subtle source of inspiration, beauty and joy in our day-to-day existence.

A favorite piece of art can be deeply meaningful and makes sense in an irrational nonverbal way. It’s that emotional, “right brain” wisdom—which speaks to and of our personal truth (that belongs solely to us). It can’t be quantified. It affects us through what Freud called “primary process” (in other words, the language of dreams) at a subliminal or unconscious level. One interior association or evoked emotion collides into the next, to pull apart and merge again. Art is an emotional bridge… to that deeper part of ourselves.

Does every picture tell a story? Or to paraphrase Freud, is sometimes a picture “just a picture?” Sometimes the art we like or choose to live with is an expression of one’s identity, cultural heritage, or personal history. It’s a proud announcement and affirmation of who we are. If in art, the person likes boats or dolls or animals or leisurely crowd scenes along the French Riviera or designs from the Ming dynasty, it makes sense that this would be something that is meaningful to that individual, even as a favorite pastime.

But more often the response to art does seem to reflect something even more internal. If we decorate and live with it, perhaps it connects us to a type of ideal or desired place or feeling in our mind. It can help create that sense of haven, a private emotional space in the midst of the world where we relax, replenish, contemplate, and nourish ourselves and our goals. Even one piece of art, however humble, can set a tone—from tranquil quiet to energized passion to uplifting inspiration. It can also be disturbing. In fact, this can be so powerful that I’ve heard some artists and art collectors say they can’t always live in their home surroundings with the intense art that they love. It’s just too evocative.

Art is a major vehicle of personal meaning and symbol. Through the nonverbal symbols in the painting or piece before us, we can obtain some insight into what are our powerful issues. Through our reactions to different works of art, we open up an avenue of self-understanding and questions we need to ask ourselves. On the negative side, sometimes this can be quite painful, raw, or threatening. A repressed memory, issue, or unwelcome feeling may be churned up… or something about the artwork suggests an unwanted aspect of ourselves. At the same time, a door is opened to our imagination and all the possibilities that lie within. We can explore, process, experiment, problem-solve, and “work through” existential and emotional questions.

In my work as a therapist, I have witnessed how art can exorcise personal demons and resolve issues, sometimes with a finality that hours of talking therapy will not achieve. For example, many people upon seeing Edvard Munch’s “The Scream” or Rodin’s sculpture “The Thinker” can identify with the anger and despair of the former or the contemplative detachment of the latter as it applies to something in their own life. In art therapy, the client actually creates art as a method of expression of what’s going on within. The person seems to “get it out” by producing an external manifestation of the problem or pain. Even through appreciation alone, a profound “cleansing” effect can occur vicariously through the work of another (usually an artist that the individual does not know personally, but who has captured in their work an essential psychological dilemma that the individual is experiencing). In this case, just resonating with the art allows the person to bring it to the surface (where it can be expressed and dealt with better) by identifying with an artistic depiction of the same problem or pain that the individual feels within.

But, while art creates the most intimate and uniquely personal response, it also paradoxically transcends the personal, connecting us to universal values and those experiences that we all share, face, struggle with, and enjoy as part of the human condition. The power of art lies in the ability to cut through personal head trips, learned biases, defense mechanisms, and the petty concerns we so often focus on. Going beyond language and sometimes culture, it provides unique opportunities for communication and healing on an interpersonal level. I think about one aunt, who I loved but with whom there was always a little bit of tension. We were very different in personality, political and religious views, friends, musical tastes—in other words, almost everything. Yet going to an art museum one day, we barely spoke as we absorbed it all, but it became clear how much we were sharing the experience, each of us responding to the emotional and imaginative power around us. This connection became an unspoken bond between us, and we spent several wonderful afternoons together in museums after that. I will always cherish those afternoons.

Back to my wall of postcards, now tattered and well past their prime. In one apartment I lived, for a period of time there was a lot of construction going on by various workers, mostly who spoke languages other than English. Inevitably, at some point during the day, I would find one of the men fixated in front of the postcards, just taking in the images and in deep reflection. Upon seeing me, they often appeared flustered, as though caught in an intensely private moment. Then, to break the ice, smiling (and often with great energy), both of us would begin pointing at one postcard or another and through a type of pantomime were able to communicate how it made us feel. And that’s another power of art, which is a universal, emotional language, transcending barriers. We connect and share through the artist’s experience, not only with our deepest self, but as one human being to another.

 

Creative Commons License
Psychmaster/Judy Marshall Articles by Judy Marshall, Ph.D. is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at https://www.psychmaster.com/psychmaster-terms-of-use.html.
Judy Marshall
About Judy Marshall
California | United States

Dr. Judy Marshall received her doctorate in clinical psychology from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. In thirty years of clinical practice in New York and Los Angeles, she has worked with many different groups, from children to the frail elderly, with particular interests including self-esteem, depression, sensitivity, and creativity.

Care to Share?

Articles By Judy Marshall

A SPIRITUAL APPROACH TO HOLIDAY BLUES

For most American adults, the period from Thanksgiving though New Year’s is a difficult time. We seem to be plunged into a virtual reality somewhere between a carnival and a nightmare. The streets and the malls are filled with lights, holiday melodies, and glittery ornaments. [Read more...] [En español]

ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: Reality And Mystery

As people live longer, the specter of Alzheimer’s looms grimly on the horizon. A disease involving progressive brain deterioration, Alzheimer’s results in increasing deficits in mental functioning and behavior. By the middle and later stages, the individual is entirely dependent on others for protection and physical care on a round-the-clock basis. [Read more...] [En español]

COPING WITH TRAUMA

The concepts of “stress” and “trauma” are broadly understood by almost everyone in modern society. In fact, we often use the words “stressed” and “traumatic” to describe our reactions to everyday events. Generally, with “stress” and “trauma,” what we are talking about are difficult, sometimes devastating situations that occur in the course of living. [Read more...] [En español]

DEPRESSION: A Negative “Altered” State?

Depression is one of the most painful of human experiences. People who are depressed may actually hurt. When we are depressed, every aspect of our experience is affected. The world tends to look dark, foreboding, or distant. The future seems bleak. Human contact becomes aversive. [Read more...] [En español]

MENTAL ILLNESS: Stigma And Reality

As a society, we are not well informed regarding mental health and illness. This is particularly surprising because we are relatively knowledgeable regarding physical health and illness. Certainly, there is a stigma attached to mental disorder or even unhappiness, despite the politically correct and ostensibly tolerant attitudes of our times. [Read more...] [En español]

ON BEING A SENSITIVE PERSON

By the time I was seven or eight years old, I had classified myself as a sensitive person. This was neither a good nor a bad thing. In my burgeoning self-awareness in the world I was discovering, I just knew I was one of those people who seemed very soft and gentle around the edges. [Read more...] [En español]

POSITIVE STRATEGIES FOR COPING WITH HOLIDAY BLUES

The holidays are a time of obvious contradictions and marked extremes. It is a season that invokes the highest spiritual ideals, yet spawns the crassest materialism. From Thanksgiving on, there is a palpable, busy ebullience and expectation “in the air,” which engulfs all of us. [Read more...] [En español]

SPIRITUALITY & RECOVERY

As a psychologist with over twenty years of clinical experience, I believe that spirituality can transform personal psychology. After evaluating hundreds of people through the legal system, I began to notice that—no matter what the religion or country of origin—people who had faith or spirituality in their lives seemed to react similarly to trauma and challenges, but differently from those who were not spiritually involved. [Read more...] [En español]

SPIRITUALITY: Jumpstarting A Cycle Of Psychological Transformation?

There is a general consensus that spirituality is good for you. This may be the only point of agreement about spirituality these days. Traditionally associated with religion or the occult, spiritual belief and practice in the 21st century are variously and often personally defined. [Read more...] [En español]

SPIRITUALITY: Living Philosophy

In recent years, there has been a rebirth of interest in spirituality. Many people describe regular spiritual practice, which may or may not include affiliation with a traditional church or religious organization. Books and materials on spirituality have become big business. [Read more...] [En español]

THE CHALLENGE OF SENSITIVITY

Even in the simplest language, the word “sensitive” has positive and negative connotations. On the positive side, being “sensitive” implies a nice and caring person, someone who is considerate, understanding, and mindful of others. On the negative side, being “sensitive” can also mean a tendency to take things too personally, a touchiness, or tendency to overreact emotionally. [Read more...] [En español]

THE STORY OF THE OLD FARMER

There once was an old farmer who lived in a remote region of the mainland, where the terrain is rough and the villagers manage to eek out a meager existence only through hard work and the grace of God. One day someone left the gate open on the farmer’s pasture, and his only horse ran away. [Read more...] [En español]

WHAT IS SCHIZOPHRENIA?

Schizophrenia is the most disabling and serious of all mental disorders. It is what is usually associated with insanity. All societies describe some variant of schizophrenia-like “madness.” In fact, the rate of occurrence is more or less similar throughout the world. [Read more...] [En español]

ART: An Emotional Bridge?

When I was in my early teens, I tried to spend every Saturday I could at the local art museum, sneaking into the city without my parents’ permission. Smaller than the Metropolitan in New York, but still noteworthy (not that I would have known), the museum was extraordinary and wondrous to me. [Read more...]

MAKING ART: A Spiritual Opening?

I never could draw well. But as a child, that never stopped me. My passion to make art was undaunted. I particularly loved color, especially all the different shades of reds and blues. For hours I would line up the crayons from my 64 superbox with great care, as though each was a cherished doll and had its own place and personality. [Read more...]

PROOF VERSUS FAITH (A Perspective)

As someone who is more intuitive than logical by nature, I’ve never had a real need for proof. That being said, for many years into my adult life, I didn’t have a real need for God, either. I was more than happy to credit my intuitions to my sensitive nature and a kind of agnostic assumption that there were energies “out there” and between human beings that no one could clearly define. [Read more...]